meeting, brainstorming, business, teamwork, team, people, office, group, corporate, conference, colleagues, company, partnership, project, table, partners, plan, sketch, notepad, coworkers, writing, drinks, laptop, computer, notes, working, meeting, meeting, meeting, meeting, business, business, business, business, business, teamwork, team, team, team, people, office, office, office, company
Photo by StartupStockPhotos on Pixabay

Reviews

Part of How to judge social media agencies reviews and verify claims before shortlisting

How to shortlist a social media agency

Shortlist a social media agency in six steps: set inclusion criteria, request the same evidence pack, score with a weighted rubric and take three agencies to paid discovery.

This is an editorial pen name used by the publication, not a claim of an independently verified personal identity. Original editorial credit: Editorial Desk.

How to shortlist a social media agency

Shortlisting is the step between a long list of agencies and a paid discovery phase. The aim is three agencies you can compare fairly, each backed by evidence. This guide gives six steps, a weighted scoring rubric, the questions to ask and a worked scoring example. The example agencies are illustrative, not real providers.

Step 1: Define the assignment and retainer band

Write down the service you need before contacting anyone: which channel or channels, the monthly retainer band, the UK nation, the expected start date and the sector. A one-channel brief and a multi-channel brand brief attract different agencies.

The campaign brief should hold these details so every agency answers the same question.

Step 2: Settle the procurement route

Check whether you are a public body. Public-sector buyers in England, Wales and Northern Ireland follow the Procurement Act 2023, which came into force on 24 February 2025 and applies to procurements started on or after that date. Scotland has its own procurement regulations. See the Procurement Act guidance.

A private company has no statutory procedure and can invite agencies directly. Record which route applies before comparing responses. The regulatory checklist covers the other rules to settle before you sign.

Step 3: Set inclusion criteria

Use pass-or-fail criteria to cut a long list before any scoring:

  • The agency works on your channel and sector.
  • Its minimum retainer fits your band. Very large networks often work to larger minimum budgets, so ask.
  • It can name the account lead who will do the day-to-day work.
  • It declares any client that competes with you.
  • It can work with your UK nation and working hours, if that matters.

Drop any agency that fails one criterion and note why. This is where seven names become three or four.

Step 4: Request the same evidence pack

Ask every remaining agency for the same pack, then read the packs side by side.

Evidence pack to request

  • Two contactable references
  • Sample monthly report, client data redacted
  • Named account lead
  • Written fee schedule
  • Read packs side by side

Case studies should name the client, the goal and the result in numbers you can check with a reference. Treat a certification such as LinkedIn's Ads certification as evidence of staff training, not proof of campaign performance. Ask for a sample monthly report with client data redacted so you can see how results are explained.

Step 5: Score with a weighted rubric

Score each agency from 0 to 5 on six criteria, then multiply by the weight. These weights suit a retainer buyer. Change them before you read any responses, not afterwards.

Weighted agency scoring rubric

Criterion

Sector fit
Relevant work, references
Team and location
Who does the work
Measurement
Reporting model, analytics access
Evidence of skill
Certifications, training records
Commercial terms
Fee, notice, renewal
Compliance
Data handling, ad rules

What you score

Sector fit
20%
Team and location
15%
Measurement
20%
Evidence of skill
15%
Commercial terms
15%
Compliance
15%

Weight

Sector fit
Team and location
Measurement
Evidence of skill
Commercial terms
Compliance

The six criteria are sector fit (20%), team and location (15%), measurement (20%), evidence of skill (15%), commercial terms (15%) and compliance (15%).

Worked example. Three illustrative agencies score as follows, in the order sector fit, team, measurement, skill, commercial terms, compliance.

  • Agency A scores 4, 3, 4, 3, 4, 4. That is 16 + 9 + 16 + 9 + 12 + 12 = 74 out of 100.
  • Agency B scores 5, 2, 3, 4, 3, 3. That is 20 + 6 + 12 + 12 + 9 + 9 = 68.
  • Agency C scores 3, 4, 5, 2, 5, 4. That is 12 + 12 + 20 + 6 + 15 + 12 = 77.

Ranking is C, A, B. Add a veto rule: a score of 0 or 1 on team or compliance removes an agency whatever its total. Treat totals within a few points as ties and decide on the questions in step 6.

Step 6: Ask the right questions in discovery

Put the same questions to every agency, in writing, and keep the answers with the scores.

  • Who will manage the account each day, and who sits in the pitch?
  • Can you speak to two current clients on a similar retainer?
  • Which reports do we receive, and do we get read access to our own analytics accounts?
  • How are ad rules handled? The ASA's CAP Code applies to social ads and influencer content.
  • How do you handle our customer data under UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018?
  • What are the notice period, the data handover and who owns creative assets at exit?

Ask for a written fee schedule rather than relying on market bands, which differ by scope. The costs and budget guide explains how to plan a budget. Use our own checks before you brief and how to verify claims before shortlisting to read similar answers consistently.

What to record

Keep a one-page record: the criteria, each agency's score, who was dropped and why, and the open questions you take into paid discovery. A shortlist is not an appointment. Notice, data handover and ownership stay open until contract stage.

  • Describe the assignment and retainer band before approaching agencies.
  • Settle the procurement route before invitations go out.
  • Apply pass-or-fail inclusion criteria and record why agencies drop.
  • Request the same evidence pack from every agency.
  • Score with the same weights and apply the veto rule.
  • Ask every agency the same written questions, then take three to paid discovery.

More in Reviews